What if...

Kevin Sorbo

Ben Walker

Kristy Swanson

Wendy Walker

John Ratzenberger

Mike the Angel

Debby Ryan

Kimberly Walker

Kristin Minter

Cynthia

Toni Trucks

Claire

Taylor Groothuis

Megan Walker

Stelio Savante

Joel Muller

Kevin Yon

Charlie

Grant James

Henryk Zimmerman

Brittany Risner

Brittney

Suzanne Lang

Front Desk Nurse

Liam Matthews

Night Nurse

Danielle Hoetmer

Elaine

Dallas Jenkins

Gas Station Attendant

Richard Pierre-Louis

Guardian Angel

Tom McElroy

James McCutcheon

Thomas Flannery Jr.

Carl

Preston Mulligan

Dylan

Dennis Lee Kelly

Ross Bessette

Brad Heller

Ross Bessette Jr.

Russell Wolfe

Car Salesman

James Daniels

Obnoxious Husband

Sharon M. Hayes

Obnoxious Woman

Maya Jenkins

Young Kimberly

Mary Thornton

Bus Station Announcer (voice)

Abbie Finner

Girl in Church (uncredited)

Madison Hertel

Party Attendee (uncredited)

Daniel James Wrzesinski

Bus Station Employee (uncredited)