Neverland

Rick Sparks

Peter Pan

Melany Bell

Wendy Darling

Wil Wheaton

John Darling

Marcus Reynaga

Michael Darling

David Jahn

George Darling

Deborah Quayle

Mary Darling

Kari Wahlgren

Tinker Bell

Joey

Nana

Stephanie Kirchen

Liza

Gary Kelley

James Hook

Scott Mechlowicz

Sam "Smee" Smiegel

Ryan Patrick Kelly

Tootles

Ian Mantha

Slightly

Eli Swanson

Curly

Zach Cole

Nibs

Tyler Kremer

Twin

Nathan Towry

Twin

Ray Garcia

Tiger Lily

Kevin Christy

Crocodile

Karim Imam

Cecco

Gilberto Aguilera

Starkey

Richard John Walters

Bill Jukes

Steven Reiswig

Cookson

Jake Winsryg

Tinker Bell's Kid

Reed Prescott

Boyfriend

Craig Jackman

Park Announcer

Saadia Billman

Mermaid

Jill Kocalis

Mermaid

Elena Fabri

Mermaid

Karen Blake Challman

Indian

Monica Louwerens

Indian

Al Bee

Indian

Red Savage

Indian

Roman Vasquez

Indian

Yayoi Ito

Indian