The Next Best Thing

Madonna

Abbie Reynolds

Rupert Everett

Robert Whittaker

Benjamin Bratt

Ben Cooper

Malcolm Stumpf

Sam

Josef Sommer

Richard Whittaker

Suzanne Krull

Annabel

Linda Larkin

Kelly

Illeana Douglas

Elizabeth Ryder

Michael Vartan

Kevin Lasater

Lynn Redgrave

Helen Whittaker

Neil Patrick Harris

David

Mark Valley

Cardiologist

Stacy Edwards

Finn

John Carroll Lynch

Abbie's Lawyer

Fran Bennett

Judge Tracey Bennett

Ricki Lopez

Angel

Tiffany Paulsen

Young Mother

Jack Betts

Vernon

Irene Roseen

Lena

Caitlin Wachs

Rachel

Jessica Sara

Kid #3

Kimberley Davies

Hostess

Laurent Schwaar

Restaurant Manager

Rebekah Hoyle

Orderly (uncredited)

Greg Bronson

Pedestrian (uncredited)

Colton Ford

Glen

Lee Lucas

Party Guest #2

Frank James

Dad at Airport

Benjamin Koldyke

Kelly's Boyfriend